Comment INFORMA 26.11.2011
==> Reply by Christian Heidorn 04.01.2010
Tables and graphs reformatted to paper publication standards.
Text adapted for EN language.
Some text moved to follow more closely the standard document structure of a YB article (intro, main findings, meta-data and context).
Many of the values in the text are not covered by the content of the Excel workbook provided. We have therefore not been able to verify some of the data in the text.
==> The data has been checked and the totals figures in the text are usually totals from the tables in the EXCEL sheet.
In the sentence "Certain risk-phrases related to chronic human toxicity are also included" there was a link to a Wikipedia entry – we do not think it is a good idea for ESTAT to redirect readers of SE to a non-official source of information and hence removed the link.
==> well done
SPECIFIC CHANGES TO XLS FILE
Figure 1
Note that 2009 data is not in Eurobase and that the 2008 data is slightly different - we imagine these will be revised before the YB is released so the data are included in Eurobase?
==> see text in Excel sheet, updates will be done in the coming days.
Figure 2
Note we are unsure what PRODCOM codes were used for the headings and as such we were unable to check the data.
==> see text in Excel sheet, the Prodcom codes will be given in the meta data sheet (still to be created).
If similar to the two other Figures then particular care should be taken to ensure that the data for 2007-2009 is correct and aligned with the data on Eurobase in advance of the YB being published.
==> see text in Excel sheet, updates will be done in the coming days.
Figure 3
Note that 2009 data is not in the table on Eurobase and that the 2007 and 2008 data is slightly different - we imagine these will be revised before the YB is released so the data in the table are included in Eurobase?
==> see text in Excel sheet, updates will be done in the coming days.